In a recent lecture on declining birthrates, I mentioned pronatalist worries about a corresponding decline in our ability to solve problems and address crises, due mainly to the aging of the population. Creative thinking, according to this argument, is primarily an attribute of youth. Most environmentalists find this thesis unconvincing if not absurd. Creativity, they contend, is not limited to youth, and that even if it were, there will still be enough young creative minds even in countries with the lowest birthrates.
The idea that an aging society might be hobbled by a decline of creativity and vigor is not a fringe position, nor is it restricted to conservative pronatalists. Consider, for example, this recent passage from liberal New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof:
In an aging and perhaps enfeebled world, Africa will also be a continent of youth — arguably making it comparatively vigorous and more of a hotbed for entrepreneurship and for music and popular culture. In a sign of increasing cultural influence, Africans in recent years have won both the Booker Prize and the Nobel Prize in Literature.
The scientific literature on age and creativity is large but no definitive answers have been reached. Some evidence suggests that creativity tends to decline with age in some domains but not in others. In fields in which raw mental power, along with the ability to think outside of established frameworks, are essential, breakthroughs often come early. Mathematics and physics are prime examples: Issac Newton developed calculus in his early and mid-twenties; Alfred Einstein was 26 when he wrote four groundbreaking papers, one of which established special relativity. In contrast, in fields in which the accumulation of knowledge and the honing of judgement are crucial, such as history and literature, age can be an advantage. This distinction is sometimes framed in terms of the difference between “fluid intelligence” and “crystalized intelligence.”
Songwriting is an intriguing area for musing on this question, as it combines the distinctive domains of musical composition and poetry. Poetry might seem to be good example of a field in which experience can be beneficial, but a vast trove of acclaimed poetry has been composed by the young. (John Keats died at 26, Percy Shelley at 29, and even Lord Byron made it only to 36.) Musical composition, in contrast, might seem favor the young, but some of the world’s most celebrated composers retained their powers into advanced age, including Johann Sebastian Bach, Ludwig van Beethoven, and Giuseppe Verdi. All told, one might expect some decline in creativity among songwriters. But – yet again – examples to the contrary are not hard to find. Leonard Cohen recorded his most beloved song, “Halleluiah,” in his late 40s, and his three final and widely celebrated albums were produced when he was in his late seventies and early eighties.
Yet when I casually consider the works of songwriters who came to fame in the 1960s and ‘70s and remained active for decades, most seem to have experienced some dimming of their creative spark as they aged. At 82, Paul McCartney continues to produce quality work, and he recently announced that he been “working on a lot of songs” that he hopes to finish and record in 2025. But I doubt that many critics would claim that his post-Beatles output, produced over 54 years, shows more creativity than the songs that he recorded with the Beatles over an eight-year period. (McCartney did, of course, share songwriting credit with the equally brilliant John Lennon in his early and mid-twenties, but most of the Beatles songs that he sang were essentially of his own creation.) As creativity declines, moreover, songwriting effort seems to increase. If I recall correctly, Paul Simon once said that in his youth songs simply poured out, whereas the older he became, the harder he had to work.
Bob Dylan makes an excellent case to consider the relationship between age and songwriting creativity. Dylan is widely regarded as the greatest songwriter of our time – if not of all time – and his output is vast (over 600 songs). He has worked in many genres yet is highly distinctive. He also continues to receive critical acclaim for his new songs. In 2021, 80 relatively well-known musicians were asked to name their favorite Dylan song to honor his 80th birthday, and five picked something from his 2020 album, Rough and Rowdy Ways. But as creative as he still is, I do see a descent over time. I also think that most critics and fans would agree.
This hypothesis might be testable, and least to some minimal degree. Many assessments have been made of Dylan’s greatest songs, by critics and others. The songs that are so acclaimed might serve as a reasonable proxy for his creativity, allowing one to graph his best output against his age (see the figures posted below).
Although the sources that I consulted vary significantly in the songs that they selected, the general pattern is clear. Dylan – in the imaginations of those who assess him – peaked in his early and mid-twenties. (As Joan Baez memorably put it, he “burst on the scene already a legend.”) The ranking of his work then plummets when he reached his late twenties, only to rebounded in his early and mid-thirties. But according to the critical consensus, he would never regain his previous heights. By his 40s, according to most sources, Dylan was writing few if any great songs. Although many critics have opined that he “returned to form” in his mid-50s, few of his songs from that period – and beyond – make the lists of his best. The general consensus seems to be that Dylan’s output from his early and mid-twenties outweighs everything that came later.
To sum it up, most observers agree that Dylan has experienced creative decline with age. But it is equally important to note that the downward slope has not been even, and that he has remained an impressively creative songwriter to this day. Youth helps, it would seem, but other factor are always at play. Dylan’s artistic decline in his late twenties, for example, may have had less to do with a drop in creativity than with devotion to family life. Consider, for example, these sweet but unremarkable lyrics from “Sign in the Window” (1970):
Build me a cabin in Utah
Marry me a wife, catch rainbow trout
Have a bunch of kids who call me “Pa”
That must be what it’s all about
That must be what it’s all about
The first graph is derived from asking ChatGPT to list Dylan’s “best songs by critical consensus.” I start with AI because it tends to give a bland overarching view, derived from numerous sources. The list that it provided clearly shows the pattern that I described above, albeit without the “long tail” found among the more knowledgeable and perceptive critics. The next figure purportedly graphs the collective assessment of “Dylan fans.” The same pattern is seen, although in simplified form. Ditto for the next two graphs, each of which is limited to his ten best songs.
The next set of figures are derived from longer lists. That of ShortList is somewhat unusual in showing a clear peak in his mid-twenties, relatively little resurgence in his thirties, and a long tail as he aged. One37PM, in contrast, has Dylan peaking in his early twenties. American Songwriter does so as well, and includes only one song written after his mid-thirties. Music Grotto also has an attenuated tail, but does contain one recent song (“Murder Most Foul”). In contrast, Paste includes many songs written after 1980. It also shows a smaller-than-usual decline in his late twenties, and rates the work of his early and mid-thirties at a higher-than-average level.
Rolling Stone has the most comprehensive list, as is fitting for a publication named after one of Dylan’s most famous songs (“Like a Rolling Stone,” which it places in the top slot). The overall pattern that it depicts, however, is fairly typical. Rolling Stone does, however, include a higher percentage of songs written in the early 1980s than is usual, as this is generally seen as the low point in his career. (The songs in question are: “The Groom’s Still Waiting at the Altar” [1980]; “Someone’s Got a Hold of My Heart” [1983]; “Sweetheart Like You” [1983]; “Jokerman” [1983]; and “Blind Willie McTell” [1983].)
Dylan’s 1997 album Time Out of Mind is regarded by many critics as marking a significant reappearance of excellence after years of disappointing ventures. As the Wikipedia article on the album notes:
For many fans and critics, the album marked Dylan’s artistic comeback after he appeared to struggle with his musical identity throughout the 1980s … .Time Out of Mind is one of Dylan’s most acclaimed albums, and it went on to win three Grammy Awards including Album of the Year in 1998.
But while a few songs from Time Out of Mind appear on several of the longer lists graphed below, the period in which it was written does not really stand out on these figures. There may have been a “return to form,” but it was evidently nothing like the form that he had reached in his early and mid-twenties.
(Several clarifications must be said about the graphs posted below. First, the age categories are based on the year in which he wrote the song in question, not the year in which it was recorded or released. Songs on the celebrated album Blood of the Tracks are conventionally dated to 1975, but most were written in 1974. The time brackets that I employ, dividing the decades of Dylan’s career into three segments, are of unequal length: four years for the “early” portion of each 10-year span, and three years for the “mid” and “late” portions. (I think it is safe to assume that most of us regard persons aged 20, 21, 23, and 23, as being in their “early” twenties, with “mid-twenties” reserved for those aged 24, 25, and 26, and so on.) Also to note is the fact that breaks on the graph often fail to correspond with breaks in Dylan’s style. His early electric songs, such as “Subterranean Homesick Blues” and “Maggie’s Farm,” are graphed as being from his early twenties, as they were written in 1964 when he was 23, although they were released in 1965 and are associated with his mid-twenties phase, the origin of which is chronicled in the second half of the recent film, A Complete Unknown.)










