Recent Focused Series »

Indo-European Origins
Siberia
Northern California
The Caucasus
Imaginary Geography
Home » Cultural Geography, Gender News, Population Geography, Russia, Ukraine, and Caucasus

Abortion and Birth Control Policies and Practices Differ in Russia, Belarus, and Ukraine

Submitted by on December 21, 2012 – 4:46 am 9 Comments |  
While in Western countries the issue of abortion concerns the legality of pregnancy termination (and it is more generally a women’s rights issue), in Eastern Europe the high rates of abortion present a bigger problem. But not all countries in the former Soviet bloc follow the same trends when it comes to birth control practices. A recent paper by one of our readers, demographer Boris Denisov and his colleagues Victoria I. Sakevich and Aiva Jasilioniene, published in PLoS ONE, shows that “the last decade witnessed growing differences in abortion dynamics in Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine despite demographic, social, and historical similarities of these nations”. Having analyzed official abortion and contraceptive use statistics, provided by national statistical agencies and respective laws from the three countries, the researchers found a growing gap in abortion rates in Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine.

According to official statistics, in 1990 all three countries had very high abortion rates. Over the subsequent two decades, Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine all achieved a significant decrease in the number of abortions. However, the speed of this improvement that was nearly equal in all the three countries during the 1990s started to diverge in the early 2000s, showing a steeper progress in Ukraine and especially in Belarus compared to Russia. In Belarus the annual speed of reduction in abortion rates accelerated from 8% to 11%, in Russia it slowed down to 5%, while in Ukraine it continued at the same annual pace of 6%. As a result, today Russia exhibits substantially higher abortion rates compared to Belarus and Ukraine, whose figures are comparable to those of the United States, England and Wales, Sweden, and France. Why such differences between Russia and its Slavic sister-countries?

In the former Soviet Union, the three republics were very much alike in terms of culture, economic development, and demographic patterns. In spite of the two decades of independent development, principal demographic characteristics of the three nations are still very similar: all three countries experience low total fertility rates of 1.3–1.5 and high prevalence of one-child families. After a brief period of above-replacement-level fertility rates in the 1980s, Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine all experienced a sharp fertility downturn during the times of political and economic turmoil of the 1990s, with a slight recovery in recent years. Also shared was the “abortion culture” during the Soviet times, that is frequent use of induced abortion as a means of birth control. Since the earlier ban on abortion was repealed in 1955, abortion on request has been legally permitted up to 12 weeks of pregnancy (later-term abortions were permitted for medical reasons only); in 1987 the Soviet Ministry of Health permitted abortions in later stages of pregnancy under additional circumstances, such as pregnancy resulting from a rape, or divorce or death of the father during pregnancy. In the post-Soviet period there have not been any principal changes in abortion laws of the three countries; abortion procedure and related services are included in the basic package of state-provided health care guarantees.

Since the discrepancies in abortion rates cannot be accounted for by differences in abortion legislation, Denisov and colleagues propose to look for an explanation in terms of contraceptive knowledge and practices. While there are no legal barriers to using contraception (except with sterilization, which is subject to legal restrictions), the three countries exhibit different rates of contraceptive use: in Belarus 41% of women used either hormonal contraceptives or IUDs in 2010, in Ukraine 32% of women did, while in Russia the corresponding figure was only 25%. The researchers also concluded that “governmental policies play an important role in shaping contraceptive practices as well as achieving the shift from abortion to contraception being used for family planning purposes”. It is in such governmental policies that differences between Russia, Belarus, and Ukraine are particularly prominent. The Russian government changed its position on family planning in the late 1990s–early 2000s. Under pressure from the segments of society holding traditionalist views, including the Orthodox Church, which seems to exert an especially strong influence in Russia, the government has adopted a strongly pro-natalist course, viewing birth control as synonymous with low fertility, which is in turn perceived as the root cause of Russia’s demographic problems. Abortion is often presented as both detrimental to a woman’s health and as morally unacceptable, but at the same time the promotion of contraceptive is very limited. Many of the centers for family planning created in the 1990s are gradually being closed due to lack of funding. If the present trends continue, or if additional legal measures are taken by Russian government to restrict birth control, the researchers predict that the abortion gap between Russia and neighboring Belarus and Ukraine will grow ever more significant.

 

Previous Post
«
Next Post
»

Subscribe For Updates

It would be a pleasure to have you back on GeoCurrents in the future. You can sign up for email updates or follow our RSS Feed, Facebook, or Twitter for notifications of each new post:
        

Commenting Guidelines: GeoCurrents is a forum for the respectful exchange of ideas, and loaded political commentary can detract from that. We ask that you as a reader keep this in mind when sharing your thoughts in the comments below.

  • http://www.facebook.com/rfmcdonald Randy McDonald

    Speaking about Ukraine, it’s worth noting that there are marked divisions between the west/centre and the east/south. Broadly speaking, fertility and birth rate are higher and death rates lower–in parts of the west and in Kyiv, there would actually be natural increase.

    pollotenchegg.livejournal.com is the best Ukrainian demography blog I’m familiar with.

    • http://www.pereltsvaig.com Asya Pereltsvaig

      Thanks for the comment and the link, Randy! You are absolutely right about the differences in demographic parameters in western and eastern Ukraine; some of this is reflected in the above map of abortion rates. I didn’t have space to get into this in detail in this brief post, but it’s a worthy topic to pursue for sure.

    • BorisDenisov

      Russia is also rather (very) heterogenous in terms of abortion

      + Asya, one objection = abortion culture, we wrote about it in another paper http://www.dia-dem.de/downloads/tr_denisov_sakevich_2009_en.pdf (English) and http://demography.ru/denisov/depot/lr9may5.pdf (Russian), with argument that the wording is an oxymoron

      ++ thank you for promoting our paper ;)

      • http://www.pereltsvaig.com Asya Pereltsvaig

        You are welcome!

        It would be interesting to take a closer look at some of those regional differences in abortion rates. Do you have a paper on this?

        As for “abortion culture”, yes in a way it is an oxymoron (thanks for further links!), but when I wrote this I had in mind what was my impression of the prevalent attitude in the Soviet times: you were not quite a woman if you didn’t have an abortion, or two, or three. It was extremely common, normal, everyday sort of thing…

        • BorisDenisov

          Actually, research shows that 1/3 of women has no abortion at all, 1/3 has one, and 1/3 has more than 1. Guess, that time changes to the first proportion is approaching 1/2

          • http://www.pereltsvaig.com Asya Pereltsvaig

            You mean during Soviet times? Maybe. Still, 2/3 women having at least one abortion seems pretty high to me.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Saim-Dušan-Inayatullah/100000494491873 Saim Dušan Inayatullah

      That’s interesting given the ethnolinguistic demographics of those areas. It seems that the more Ukrainian parts of the country have higher fertility rates while the more Russian parts are more like Russia…

  • http://caravanistan.com Steven

    Other countries of FSU still have tons of abortions – see this article on Kyrgyzstan for instance http://www.eurasianet.org/node/66218 Also in Kazakhstan I hear stories (gossip maybe more accurate word here) about women having 6-7 abortions – before they are 21!

    • http://www.pereltsvaig.com Asya Pereltsvaig

      Thank you for sharing this.

  • Pingback: Population panic: Homophobia, Islamophobia, anti-feminism, and the new right-wing politics of birth | a paper bird