Declining Human Fertility and Urbanization in the United States

A recent GeoCurrents post on Utah’s declining birth rate included maps of the Total Fertility Rate (TFR) of the U.S. by state in 2008 and 2022. Comparing the state-by-state data from these two years yields a map of total fertility change during this period (posted below). As this map shows, the fertility drop was, in general, more pronounced in the West than in the rest of the country. In contrast, it was less pronounced in the Midwest, along with a couple of adjacent states (Kentucky and West Virginia).

Changes in U.S. Fertility Rate by State, 2008-2022 map

This regional distinction made me wonder about the possible role of urbanization in changing fertility patterns. The two states with the most pronounced TFR drops, Utah and Nevada, are both characterized by high urbanization rates, whereas states with less pronounced declines, such as North Dakota, Iowa, West Virginia, and Kentucky, have lower urbanization rates.

The Wikipedia map of urbanization by state, however, shows that the correlation is relatively weak. Mississippi, for example, had a significantly greater fertility drops than Louisiana, yet its urbanization rate is much lower. It is intriguing, however, that Maine, the eastern state with the lowest fertility drop, also has one of the country’s lowest urbanization rates. The least urbanized state, Vermont, also had a relatively low fertility decline in this period. But the TFR of Vermont is still the lowest in the country (1.35), which was also the case in 2008 (when in was 1.67).

U.S. Urbanization Rate by State, map

Changing fertility patterns is a complex issue, one that continually challenges – if not bedevils – professional demographers. Their problems in projecting changes in this regard are glaringly evident in the Financial Times’ graph posted below. As a well-known quip of uncertain origin reminds us, “It is difficult to make predictions, especially about the future.”*

* Attributed by different sources to Niels Bohr, Samuel Goldwyn, K.K. Steincke, Robert Storm Petersen, Yogi Berra, Mark Twain, Nostradamus and “Anonymous.”

Graph of Failed UN Birth-Rate Projections

Declining Human Fertility and Urbanization in the United States Read More »