The Geography of Russian War Deaths in Ukraine Does Not Reflect the Geography of Wealth and Poverty

As noted in the previous GeoCurrents post, Russian military deaths in the Ukraine war vary greatly by region, ranging from a high of 650 per 100,000 residents in Tuva to a low of 26 in Moscow. Some sources attribute such stark differences to variations in income, with higher death rates in poorer places. But although poverty is a crucial factor at the individual level, it does offer an adequate explanation of regional patterns.

We can explore the connections between war deaths and economic standing by comparing maps of the two issues. As can be seen on the set posted below, Russian federal subjects (the primary divisions of the country) with the lowest war-mortality figures include some of the most impoverished parts of the country as well as some of the most prosperous. Examples in the former category include Chechnya and Dagestan in the North Caucasus and those in the latter include the Moscow region and Saint Petersburg. Similarly, federal subjects with high mortality figures also include some of the most prosperous parts of the country, such as resource-rich but sparsely populated Chukotka in the extreme east, as well as some of the most impoverished, such as Kirov in eastern European Russia. Overall, these maps show higher mortality rates in the relatively wealthy, resource-rich regions of northern Russia than in the poorer regions of the country’s western core.

Russian War Deaths and Average Income, map

Paired maps of western European Russia allow is to see these relationships more clearly. The Moscow region and Saint Petersburg occupy the top two tiers on the income map and the bottom two tiers on the mortality map. But Orlov Oblast and the Republic of Mordovia exhibit the opposite pattern; both are in the second lowest income tier but are lower than average on the war-deaths map. If poverty were the driving factor, one would expect higher-than-average mortality rates for these two penurious regions. (Note that ethnicity is not much of a factor here, as Orlov is overwhelmingly ethnic Russian, whereas as 40 percent of the residents of Mordovia are Mordvins, a Volga Finnic group whose members speak two related languages, Erzya and Moksha.)

War Deaths ands Income in western European Russia map

One reason for the relatively low mortality rates in Orlov and Mordovia is a a paucity of military-age men. As the table posted below shows, both regions have experienced population losses for decades, due in part to the migration of young adults to Moscow. Both regions also have extremely low birth rates, with Mordovia posting a total fertility rate below 1.0 in 2024. It is noteworthy that Kirov in eastern European Russia, a poor region with a very high war-mortality rate, has a somewhat higher fertility rate, but it is still well below the replacement rate. Kirov’s population, moreover, has dropped even more precipitously than those of Orlov and Mordovia since 1959.

Demographic Trends in Oryal and Mordovia, Russia

Kirov Russia population

Russia TFR map

When I queried AI (Grok) about these seeming incongruities, it responded with simple answer: the variation in intensity of miliary recruitment accounts for the difference in the death rates:

Kirov is poorer in similar ways (agricultural/industrial periphery, limited high-value resources, depopulation) to Orlov and Mordovia, but has sustained more aggressive or successful recruitment relative to its male population. Local authorities appear to have met higher quotas, and economic incentives have pulled in more men from its remaining working-age cohorts. Oryol and Mordovia, while also low-income and demographically depleted, have not shown the same intensity of per-adult-male losses in the available tallies. Differences can also reflect the presence or absence of certain military units or recruitment infrastructure, and the exact timing/intensity of regional campaigns.

This explanation, however, does not address the underlying issue of why military recruitment has been more aggressive and successful in Kirov than in Orlov and Mordovia. Perhaps it is an idiosyncratic matter than cannot be answered, at least from the information that I can obtain.